Coroner’s heartfelt plea for donors after Hope Valley teenager’s death

editorial image

A coroner broke into tears during the inquest of a teenager as he made a heartfelt plea for people to donate organs.

During the inquest of George Green – who died from a recognised complication after a heart transplant – coroner Robert Hunter choked back tears as doctors giving evidence revealed only 120 hearts are donated a year in the UK.

I think there needs to be a proper public debate, out in the open, because 120 hearts a year is not enough.

Coroner Dr Robert Hunter

The amount of people who need a heart transplant is approximately 16,000 a year.

George, 19, of Sunnyside Villas, Castleton, died in April 2013 after developing a routine complication with his heart transplant.

He had just finished work in Hathersage when he died of a sudden heart attack. George had his transplant operation in 2000.

Emotions at the inquest also ran high as doctors discussed how to tell young patients about transplant life-expectancy – which averages 12 years, but can cause death at any point in life.

Giving evidence on Tuesday, a medic who treated George, Dr Stephen Shaw, said: “Do you bring a patient’s world crashing down around them by saying there’s a limited chance of survival after transplant? Or do you say everything is going fine? It’s such a hard dilemma we face as doctors.”

In his conclusion, Dr Hunter said: “It’s a terrible position for children and their families. If you tell (the prospects of survival) to a young transplant patient you are effectively giving them a death sentence.”

Chesterfield Coroner’s Court heard that the only way to treat the complication which caused George’s death – Transplant Vasculopathy – was a new transplant. But as the number of critically ill people in desperate need of a new heart is so high, it is rare that a patient would get two transplants.

In George’s case, he was simply not ill enough to qualify for another heart, despite a deterioration in his condition, the inquest heard.

It is extremely rare for a coroner to become emotionally involved in proceedings, which highlights the desperation of the plea.

Dr Hunter said: “120 hearts a year for the whole of the UK is not nearly enough. I know transplant organisations are trying to promote it and persuade people to donate more, but it is a big ask to get people to donate organs... I think there needs to be a proper public debate, out in the open, because 120 hearts a year is not enough.”

He added: “I was really quite moved by the evidence. I could see that (Dr Shaw), not only with George but every patient, is truly affected. I have never seen that in a doctor giving evidence before.

“It struck me and I don’t think it should go without being noticed.”